“I love the atmosphere and the coffee. The chocolate cake is to die for.”

This is what a customer of a coffee house in Henderson, NV said when asked if he had visited the place before. To keep this customer coming back, the business needs retention marketing that focuses on his favorite products and experience factors.

In eCommerce, Shopify store owners should also focus on that “chocolate cake” their customers are looking for. A customer retention marketing strategy is the way to get there and learn what brings shoppers back.

In this guide, you'll learn how to do effective retention marketing and keep more customers.

Go to content sections:

Looking for something else? Check out these articles:

Build subscriber lists and nurture them with marketing messages

Start building my subscriber list

What is Retention Marketing?

Retention marketing means promoting a business to existing customers. This strategy is designed to encourage customers to choose the same business in the future by keeping them connected, updated, and rewarded.

The goal of retention marketing is customer retention: a company’s ability to turn its one-time buyers into repeat customers and prevent them from leaving for a competing brand. It is different from customer acquisition or lead generation, because you have already converted the customer and they are already familiar with your business. In other words, customer retention is keeping the customer with your company for as long as possible, so that they bring you income again and again.

Retention marketing happens at three levels (Leonard L. Berry):

  • Level I: Financial bonds
  • Level II: Financial and social bonds
  • Level III: Financial, social, and structural bonds

Each level brings customers a little closer to the business by rewarding them for a continuous relationship. The purpose of each marketing activity throughout this model is to develop long-term relationships with customers.

Retention Marketing: Bonding Levels

I. Financial bondsFinancial incentives to encourage customers to buy (discounts, free shipping, free products etc.)
II. Financial and social bondsFinancial incentives + personalized products and services for regular customers based on their needs, interests, and purchase history
III. Financial, social, and structural bondsStructural incentives include value-adding, unique products, features, or services available only for regular customers.
Source: Adopted from Berry, L. Relationship marketing of services - growing interest, emerging perspectives. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science.

Benefits of Customer Retention Marketing

Selling to existing customers is easier and cheaper. When online businesses collect at least 50 customers, they should focus on retaining them besides attracting new ones. This is where customer retention marketing comes in.

The benefits of using retention marketing:

  • Increase sales. About 57% of customers spend more on brands to which they are loyal (Accenture)
  • Reduce customer churn. Around 85% of customers say that businesses could do more to retain them (Customer Needs and Solutions Journal)
  • Decrease marketing costs. The cost of retaining a customer is up to five times lower than the cost of acquiring a new one (Invesp)
  • Make selling easier. The probability of selling to an existing customer is 60-70 percent. With a new prospect, your chances go down to only 5-20 percent.
  • Grow revenue per customer. Repeat customers are likely to spend 31 percent more compared to new customers. And just by increasing customer retention by 5 percent, you can boost your income by 25 percent.
  • Shorten the buyer’s journey. Customer retention is an important part of a customer lifecycle marketing strategy. It brings buyers back to the bottom of the sales funnel (the purchase stage shown below) without having them go through the whole buyer’s journey again.
  • Win new prospects. If you forge long-lasting relationships with your loyal customers, they might become your ambassadors who spread good word-of-mouth about your company and bring in new prospects.
Sales Funnel Stages
Awareness
Interest
Consideration
Intent
Evaluation
Purchase

Sales funnel showing six stages of a buyer’s journey. Starting from the top, these stages are Awareness, Interest, Consideration, Intent, Evaluation, Purchase.

Keeping customers is also one of the biggest challenges eCommerce businesses face. When it comes to buying online, customers can choose any business they want and switch to another whenever they wish. Today’s consumers have also become more demanding, especially about the speed and quality of service: based on a Zendesk report, one bad experience could be enough to cause 80 percent of customers to leave a brand for a competitor.

Achieving these benefits means doing specific strategies. Let’s look at effective customer retention marketing strategies from eCommerce businesses.

Customer Retention Marketing Strategies & Examples

Here are twelve great customer retention marketing strategies online businesses use to increase the number of repeat customers. The first eight include an example from an eCommerce brand.

1. Loyalty Programs

Rewarding loyalty is like a Starbucks coupon card: it always keeps you motivated to go buy another coffee. Customers appreciate when brands show their gratitude for shopping with them, so they are more likely to continue doing so.

That’s why 90% of companies now have some kind of a loyalty program. Customers are looking for them: in the travel industry, for example, loyalty programs are a consideration for 46% of clients.

Loyalty programs have a strong positive impact on customer retention. Based on this loyalty report, such programs motivate 72 percent of customers to recommend a brand, 78 percent to continue doing business with it, and 64 percent to spend more to maximize their loyalty points. Rewards not only entice customers into returning to your shop but also incentivize them to refer new prospects.

Loyalty Program Example: Honeybee Gardens

This Shopify store does customer retention with Honeybee VIBee Club, a loyalty program with numerous rewards. Repeat customers can earn “buzz bucks,” aka loyalty points, in many ways, including following the brand on social media, referring a friend, or simply having a birthday.

The rewards system is great because it features different perks. For various amounts of buzz bucks, customers can get discount coupons, free products, store credits, free shipping, and other bonuses. Besides, the loyalty program’ name is super creative!

honeybee loyalty program

2. Email marketing

Online businesses use emails to send customer appreciation letters, discounts, sale promos, abandoned shopping cart reminders, news about social responsibility projects, and other messages that improve customer retention.

Indeed, email marketing is a great strategy to stay connected to customers. It’s an easy and direct way to update them on brand news and sales, share useful product-related content, give discounts, and do other things to enhance loyalty.

Example: Beardbrand

Beardbrand, a men’s grooming brand, offers an amazing example of customer retention marketing with emails. Every email is written in a playful, conversational language, has great visuals, and contains plenty of website links.

The email below is an example of how the brand makes both new and repeat customers feel a connection by communicating in a unique style. Those who appreciate this kind of vibe will be interested in checking out the brand's products once more.

email example

3. Referral programs

Referral programs can improve customer acquisition and retention by rewarding repeat customers for giving you new ones. A referral bonus is another reason to continue buying, so many businesses use such programs in their retention marketing strategies.

Customers recommended by others also have a 37% higher retention rate. The explanation is simple: people trust recommendations, so they’re likely to stick with the brands their friends use, too.

Getting customers from referrals is especially important for brands that are less likely to see repeat purchases from the same buyer (for example, stores selling big and expensive goods that are bought only once in a long while, such as fridges, washing machines or electric bikes). With referral programs, you can reward ambassadors for recommending you and reward the new buyers for making their first purchase.

Referral programs also leverage the power of social proof. The customer who came to you through a personal recommendation will trust you because they trust the person who gave that recommendation. As a result, it will be easier for you to retain your new buyers, as long as you keep good relationships with them and with the customers who referred them.

Example: Stio

Stio, an outdoor apparel brand, offers $40 for referrals as a part of its retention marketing strategy. A customer gets $40 off their first order when their referral makes a purchase (who also gets $40 off).

The “Refer a friend” approach has customers endorsing your business. So, it’s an organic way to increase customer acquisition and get some word-of-mouth going. And participating in the campaign is easy: choose the method (email or link), type in an email, and share the code.

stio referral program

Referral programs are easy to make with special apps. This list of the Best Shopify Apps has both free and paid Shopify referral apps.

4. Retargeting campaigns

Retargeting marketing campaigns remind customers about products they viewed or left in a shopping cart. It’s a personalized strategy to encourage conversions that also works great for customer retention.

Retargeting campaigns keep customers updated and connected by “continuing the conversation” after they leave. Businesses do retargeting campaigns with paid pads, push notifications, emails, and other tools.

Example: ELO

ELO, a Shopify clothing store, used browser push notifications to retarget existing customers. Besides abandoned shopping cart reminders, the brand notified customers about sales in categories they browsed or bought from.

The revenue from push notification retargeting campaigns has been phenomenal. According to ELO’s CEO Umar Quamar, they bring between $6,000 and $7,000 for every $850 spent. You can read more about the campaigns and performance in this ELO Case Study.

elo push campaigns

5. Top-notch customer service

Getting a customer to buy again is just a part of a customer retention strategy - servicing them is another thing. Customer service can be a dealbreaker, as 61% of customers are likely to stop doing business with brands due to a single poor customer service experience.

That’s why businesses should do retention marketing after establishing a robust customer service system. The system can include self-help options like FAQs and real-time support tools like live chat and chatbots.

Speed matters here, too. It was found that 50 percent of adults will abandon a purchase if they do not receive a quick answer to their question. The expectation of a nearly immediate response is true for new visitors and for those who have already bought from you. With a live chat app in your store, you can assist customers while they browse your product pages, need help with checkout, or have general questions about shopping. Some of the best Shopify apps for customer service are free and very easy to install, so you can start using them in minutes.

Example: Care Package Depot

Selling personalized gift boxes requires a lot of communication with customers. That’s why Care Package Depot’s owner, Kelly, personally serves customers via live chat. It integrates with her CRM, so she has information to provide the best possible customer experience.

Customers who have questions about products can quickly get answers. This is an example of exceptional customer service that offers an easy way to get in touch with the brand and chat with the owner like you would with a friend.

live chat from care package depot

Live chat has the highest customer satisfaction rating, so it’s a great way to provide quality service. Here’s How to Use Live Chat to Generate Sales and Service Customers

6. Discounts & coupons

Many customers are looking for the best deal. That’s understandable, so discounts are useful in customer retention marketing strategies. For example, online stores share discounts with existing customers via emails or websites to establish “financial bonds” with them.

eCommerce research also supports that promotions such as discounts have a positive effect on a customer’s own perception of a product’s value.

Example: The 5TH

This watch store’s customer retention strategy involves regular discounts for both new and existing customers. The 5TH shares sales and discounts with repeat customers via email newsletters that lead them to product pages like the one below.

Customers who are interested in buying a watch would be glad to learn about the sale and the discount. It would reduce the total order cost, which is something many shoppers value.

the 5th product with discounts

Need help with making a smart discount strategy for your Shopify store? This Guide to Creating Discounts for Shopify Stores has plenty of tips and examples.

7. Social responsibility programs

Businesses that practice social responsibility try to minimize their impact on communities, the economy, and the environment. They do so by reducing their carbon footprint, engaging in philanthropic efforts, and using other ways to contribute positively to society.

Customers are more likely to become loyal to a business if they share the same views. In fact, over 84% of customers say they are inclined to be loyal to businesses whose values align with theirs.

Example: Meow Meow Tweet

Meow Meow Tweet calls itself a “positively natural” vegan skincare business. Sounds cool, but what exactly is the brand doing to stay true to that?

Meow Meow Tweet suggests these activities:

  • Keeping production low in waste through repurposing and using biodegradable materials for product packaging.
  • Using ingredients from certified plant populations to minimize the impact on the environment and communities.
  • Supporting charities in the categories of Earth & Nature, Animal Justice, and Social Justice categories by sharing profits with them every month.

Awesome values, indeed!

People whose values are aligned with these will be more likely to try the products and become repeat customers. Besides, this customer retention marketing strategy benefits customer acquisition, as many new folks might also want to learn more.

Sharing content related to these values through emails and other channels can help update customers on social responsibility news. This would reassure them that they’re buying from the right business.

meow meow tweet social responsibility program

Ivory Ella donates 10% of profits to the Save the Elephants project. Here’s how this clothing brand spreads knowledge about its social responsibility program: Ivory Ella Case Study

8. Subscription service

A subscription-based customer retention strategy involves providing the same product on a set time schedule (such as weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly). Subscription models can improve customer retention for many eCommerce businesses - from food brands to streaming services.

You can do retention marketing by sharing information about your subscription service and its benefits. Besides placing this info on product pages, write about the service on your blog and mention it in emails, SMS, etc.

Subscription service example: Gratisfied

Gratisfied, a healthy food company, allows getting subscriptions for their products.

Subscribing means receiving 10% off all products and automatic delivery according to a customer’s time schedule. For many shoppers, this offer has a lot of value, since they might not have time to visit the store often.

subscription service example

The next four strategies have no single brand example, but each of them helps every store keep more customers.

9. Omnichannel customer support

What really drives customer retention and loyalty is the ease of solving a problem. One of the key elements that will help you and your customers succeed here is good communication, ideally via multiple channels. Why not use just a single channel? Because customers have different preferences and might find it more convenient to solve their issue using, for example, email rather than a phone.

That is why offering omnichannel support is so important for smooth communication. However, omnichannel support is more than offering multiple means of contact. It also means consistent communication across different channels.

Since the customer’s history and issue description follow them from one channel to another, support agents can provide better and more personalized support. Your customers, on the other hand, do not need to explain their issues over and over again to agents from different departments.

10. Pain-free product returns

How else can you be one step ahead of your customers and make their shopping experience even better? By making the product return procedure hassle-free. When it comes to shopping online, product delivery and returns are consumers’ two biggest concerns. You can use them to your advantage and outshine your competition if you simplify the delivery and returns processes.

It will pay off: as many as 58 percent of customers stated that they would buy again from brands that ensure free and “no-questions-asked” policies, whereas 92 percent admitted they will buy again if the product return process is easy.

Consumers often read return policy pages before they decide to spend their time and money in an online shop, so make sure that your rules are clear, fair, and transparent. This will help your customers avoid bad experiences, increase their trust in your store, and encourage them to shop with you again.

11. Omnichannel marketing and personalization

Personalized communication toward each customer is not limited to customer service. It is important on all levels of communication, including marketing. So you will also need to tailor your marketing messages to be relevant to your customers’ needs. Otherwise, instead of being helpful, your messages will feel purely promotional.

This is where omnichannel marketing comes into play. What is omnichannel marketing? In essence, it is a marketing approach that spans different channels and aims to deliver customized and seamless shopping experiences to every customer, built on their behavior and the channel they use to interact with the brand. Marketing personalization boosts retention because customers expect brands to know what they want.

Nearly 90 percent of shoppers are eager to share their behavioral data to receive a more seamless brand experience. Individual customers stated they are 40 percent more willing to buy from a brand that tailors its content to suit their needs. So whether you create a social media ad, a newsletter, or a landing page, make sure it reaches only the relevant segment of your customers.

Firepush is a web push marketing app that will help you reach your customers at the right time and with the right message. Check out this comprehensive guide to the best omnichannel strategy for your Shopify store.

12. Collect customer feedback to understand reasons for churn

It is very hard to improve your business (and retain customers) if you do not know what your customers think and how they feel about your brand. To prevent customers from leaving, you will need to find out where your store’s strengths and weaknesses lie. This way, you will be able to capitalize on your strong areas and focus on the weak ones that need improvement.

There are several ways to collect customer feedback. The most common ones include surveys (for example Net Promoter Score®), interviews, user testing, and focus groups. If you are a small company that cannot easily involve customers face-to-face, surveys alone can provide a lot of valuable insights. You can build and run surveys using an online application (for example the free Google Forms).

Another very useful way of collecting feedback is customer reviews. You can add this social proof feature to your store with the dedicated Shopify review apps.

Although many apps allow for review moderation, hiding negative reviews is not a good practice. Try to deal with negative customer feedback and reviews immediately. Be open and transparent about what you have already done to fix the issues.

How to Get Started with Customer Retention Marketing

Retention marketing strategies work differently for different customer groups. So, they’ll have a good chance of working if you segment repeat customers to target retention marketing at those who are likely to be interested.

Building a successful eCommerce business is not only about acquiring new customers. It is also about retaining the existing customer pool. Customer retention and trust are the outcomes of exceptional customer experiences. Offer great products, deliver great service, and above all, make your customers’ lives easier. In return, your customers will be much more likely to stick with you and advocate for your brand.

Consider using retention marketing strategies from this guide to increase your sales. Research customers, use the three “bonding” levels, and experiment to find the best techniques. Do that and you’ll have the best chance to recover your investment and get nice profits.